The cruises compared here
On a Nile cruise you sleep on the ship but spend most of the day at the temples, so the ship matters less than on a sea cruise. Still, the listings sell it in categories, and the choice changes what you pay.
Here is what the 4-night and 3-night listings say about the boat, and what they do not.
1The three categories
Both multi-day listings list the same three categories. The 5-star standard group includes ships such as MS Pioneer II, MS Mirage, MS Nile Delta and MS Jasmin, the 5-star superior group includes MS Zeina, Royal Princess and Crown Jewel, and the luxury group is Mövenpick Royal Lilly, Mövenpick Royal Lotus and the three Sonesta Goddess ships. The standard and superior lists end with or similar vessels.
Each category is sold with or without an Abu Simbel excursion, which gives six rates per cruise. The Cairo dinner cruise is a different case: the listing says a 5-star boat, either the Nile Maxim or the Nile Pharaohs.
2What the listings do not say
They do not describe cabin size, decks or facilities, apart from a pool that is cleaned from 8 am to 12 noon. They also do not say which category the starting price of €528 or €477.95 refers to, or how much a higher one adds, so you only see the difference when you pick a rate.
The scores of 7.8 and 7.4 belong to each cruise as a whole. They are not split by ship category, so they cannot tell you whether luxury was worth it for the reviewers.
3How to choose
If price decides, start with the standard rate, since the listings do not say which category the starting price refers to and standard is the entry level. If you want a better cabin and can accept that the exact ship is assigned shortly before departure, compare the luxury rate for your dates and read what it lists before paying more.
Remember that ships in the standard and superior groups are given as examples or similar vessels, so treat the named ships as a guide, not a promise. Only the luxury list is given by name, without that wording.